Our Team

Tyler N. Sheehan

Assistant General Agent




Tyler N. Sheehan

Facebook | Linkedin

Tyler N. Sheehan, FICF, CLTC is a Financial Advisor with the Niemeyer Agency serving Brother Knights and their families in Cumberland, Effingham, Jasper and Shelby counties. Tyler joined the order in 2011 and became a Field Agent in January 2015. Tyler joined the Order because he felt it would be a great opportunity to help fellow Catholic men and their families, while still practicing his faith. "I love to lend a helping hand, and with this opportunity, I am able to help several Brother Knights and their families every year. That's what the Knights of Columbus is all about." said Tyler.

Tyler grew up in a very small town, called Trowbridge, Illinois. Early on, he saw the way small towns came together in times of need. "It's a small town where everybody knows everybody, and you can always count on somebody being there for you," said Tyler. Tyler wanted to be the go-to guy, in the time of need. He began by graduating Neoga High School in 2012. From there, he went to earn an Associates in Accounting, and a Certificate in Business Management at Lake Land College. He then began studying to become a licensed Insurance Agent. He went on to do so and has been a licensed insurance agent since November 2014. He continues his education today in Insurance.

Before Tyler's days as an Insurance Agent, he helped his father, Dan Sheehan. Dan has been an Agent with the Knights since September 2010. Dan has become a very successful agent with the Knights, achieving the Lifetime Million Dollar Round Table Award (MDRT), an honor reserved for the top one percent of financial professionals in the world. Tyler studied closely as he got sufficient experience from his father, and became a MDRT qualifier, himself.

Today, Tyler resides in Trowbridge with his wife, Brittany. They welcomed a son, Eli, in November 2021 and another son, Lucas, in August 2023. Their family attends St. Mary's of the Assumption in Neoga. Throughout his community, Tyler is involved with St. Patrick's Cemetery Board. Outside of work, Tyler referees basketball games and he loves spending his time golfing. Tyler said that you can always catch him on the golf course, every week, all year round.

Since joining the Order, Tyler has helped with many breakfasts, fish fry's, tootsie roll drives, March for Life, and several other charitable events with his local council in Neoga. Tyler enjoys helping others and will strive to meet your financial needs.

Tyler was a Supreme Knight Club qualifier for 2015, and was also rewarded with the company-wide 2015 Rookie Of The Year Award. This was a very prestigious accomplishment and reflected Tyler's hard work and perseverance throughout the year. Tyler also qualified for the Premier Performers Award Trip in 2015 (Kauai, Hawaii), 2018 (Bermuda), 2019 (Big Island, Hawaii), 2021 (Bahamas) and 2022 (Disney World, Orlando, Florida).

Tyler also provides financial and investment services under the Knights of Columbus Asset Advisors for all Central and Southern Illinois. Invest with Tyler here
Schedule an appointment today with Tyler, you'll be thankful you did.

Contact Tyler at:

Agency Team


Personalized Life Insurance

Determine how much life insurance is appropriate for your family and discover how the Knights can help protect your future today.

Members and their families get exclusive access to our top quality portfolio of life insurance, retirement annuities, disability income insurance, and long-term care insurance.